top of page

Genes, Scenes and Gattaca Dreams

Would you like fries with that? 

Cloning babies in a futuristic lab like the movie Gattaca.jpg

By  Brock Cravy



Let's dive into the fascinating narrative of the BRCA1-screened baby—a storyline that could rival the speculative depths of "Gattaca." This isn't just a debate about the ethics of designer babies; it's about scripting a new chapter in our genetic narrative.


Imagine a family with a history deeply shadowed by early-onset breast and ovarian cancer, a background so intense it could belong to a medical drama. Instead of yielding to fate, this family takes a proactive stance, choosing embryo screening with the resolve to script their genetic future themselves.


As we spotlight these potential pioneers of our genetic journey, let’s take a moment to assess the shifting landscape of risk assessments. Originally, stark warnings indicated an 82% chance of developing breast cancer by age 80. Recent studies, however, tune down this alarm to a more moderate 50-60% risk—transforming the feared monster under the bed into something closer to a cautious housecat.


The cautionary tale of "Gattaca" serves as a stark reminder of the perils that come with our venture into the realm of designer babies. We are no longer mere observers of genetics; we are its direct manipulators, holding the tools to shape evolutionary outcomes. Yet, in our quest for genetic precision, we risk overlooking the value of diversity.


BRCA1, or Breast Cancer 1, is a crucial gene functioning as a tumor suppressor. It plays a vital role in repairing damaged DNA and maintaining cellular genetic stability. A mutation in this gene fails to prevent the unchecked growth of cells, significantly raising the risk for breast and ovarian cancers.


What destiny awaits our grand genetic endeavor? Will we endlessly edit our genetic script seeking perfection, or will we appreciate that life’s beauty often lies in its unexpected twists?


As we explore this genetic frontier, we must consider the ethical implications and potential repercussions of our choices. Are we prepared to face the consequences of our genetic decisions? Is our pursuit of an ideal genome overshadowing the intrinsic worth found in human diversity?


In the dystopian world of "Gattaca," society is stratified by genetic status. Yet, in our reality, we have the opportunity to redefine that narrative—to embrace and celebrate the complex diversity that shapes human experiences.


The allure of enhanced genetics continues to seduce us with promises of healthier, smarter, and stronger descendants. But what are the costs? Are we willing to compromise the very essence of our humanity for the sake of genetic improvement?


Standing at this intersection of science and ethics, it’s imperative that we move forward with mindfulness. The tale of the BRCA1-screened baby is just one chapter in a larger saga that will define the future of humanity for generations.


Let’s proceed, not driven by a quest for genetic flawlessness, but with a profound respect for the complexities and contradictions that define our human nature. After all, it is often our imperfections that carve our identity, enrich our lives, and make the story of humanity deeply compelling.

bottom of page